Cardinals QB Situation: Who Steps Up in 2024?

The Arizona Cardinals enter the 2024 season with one of the most closely watched quarterback situations in the NFL. After a disappointing 4-13 record in 2023, many fans and analysts are questioning whether the team’s current roster can improve under center. The Cardinals have invested heavily in their offensive line and skill position players, but the quarterback position remains the biggest wildcard.

With Kyler Murray recovering from injury and questions lingering about his long-term durability, the Cardinals have explored multiple options. The front office has made it clear they are committed to finding a long-term solution, whether through free agency, the draft, or internal development. This article examines the current state of the Cardinals’ quarterback situation, the potential candidates, and what the team needs to do to compete in the NFC West.

Kyler Murray’s Future Remains Uncertain

Kyler Murray, the Cardinals’ 2019 first-round pick, has been a polarizing figure since entering the league. While he possesses elite athleticism and playmaking ability, injuries have limited his availability in recent seasons. In 2023, Murray played in just 11 games due to a lingering knee injury, and his performance was inconsistent when healthy.

The Cardinals have not ruled out Murray as their starter in 2024, but they are also exploring alternatives. General manager Monti Ossenfort has emphasized the importance of finding a quarterback who can stay on the field and lead the offense effectively. If Murray is not fully recovered or struggles in training camp, the team may look to other options.

Murray’s contract situation adds another layer of complexity. He is set to earn $29.5 million in 2024, with a cap hit of $36.5 million. If the Cardinals decide to move on from Murray, they would save $20 million in dead cap by releasing him. However, doing so would also mean forfeiting the remaining years of his rookie deal, which could be a difficult decision for the franchise.

Potential Internal and External Options

The Cardinals have several potential options at quarterback for 2024. If Murray is not ready, the team could turn to veterans or rookies to stabilize the position. Here’s a breakdown of the most likely candidates:

• Kyler Murray (if healthy) – The Cardinals’ best chance at winning is with Murray under center, but his health and performance will determine his role.
• Clayton Tune – The undrafted free agent from Houston showed promise in limited action last season. He could compete for the starting job in training camp.
• Josh Dobbs (if re-signed) – Dobbs provided a spark in 2023 before being traded to Denver. If he returns, he could serve as a veteran backup.
• Draft Picks (2024 NFL Draft) – The Cardinals hold multiple picks, including two in the first three rounds. A high-upside quarterback could enter the mix if Murray’s future is uncertain.

If the Cardinals decide to look outside the organization, they could pursue veteran free agents or trade for a quarterback. Names like Aaron Rodgers (if he becomes available) or a younger option like Anthony Richardson (if he rebounds from injury) could be on the radar. However, the Cardinals’ draft capital and cap space may limit their options in free agency.

What the Cardinals Need to Compete in the NFC West

The NFC West remains one of the toughest divisions in the NFL, with the 49ers, Rams, and Seahawks all expected to contend. For the Cardinals to compete, they need stability at quarterback and improved play from their offensive line. The Cardinals ranked 28th in sacks allowed in 2023, which put immense pressure on Murray and the offense.

Defensively, the Cardinals have made strides under new defensive coordinator Nick Rallis, but they still need to address their pass rush and secondary. If the team can find a reliable quarterback, they could emerge as a surprise contender in the division. However, without a clear answer at QB, their playoff hopes remain uncertain.

The Cardinals’ coaching staff, led by head coach Jonathan Gannon, will play a crucial role in developing the offense around whichever quarterback wins the job. If Murray is the starter, the team must manage his workload carefully. If they go with a veteran or rookie, the coaching staff will need to tailor the scheme to maximize their strengths.

Fan Reactions and Media Buzz

Cardinals fans have been vocal about the quarterback situation, with many calling for a change after years of inconsistency. Social media has been filled with debates over Murray’s future, and analysts have questioned whether the team can build a contender around him. Some fans have even floated the idea of trading up in the draft for a quarterback, though the Cardinals’ front office has not indicated that they are considering such a move.

The media has also weighed in, with some suggesting that the Cardinals could be sellers at the trade deadline if Murray struggles early in the season. Others believe the team should commit to Murray and give him one last chance to prove himself. Regardless of the approach, the quarterback situation will define the Cardinals’ 2024 season.

For more analysis on the Cardinals’ roster and strategy, check out our Sports and News sections for ongoing coverage.

Final Thoughts

The Cardinals’ quarterback situation is a microcosm of their broader challenges. The team has talent on both sides of the ball, but without a reliable signal-caller, their playoff hopes are limited. Whether they stick with Murray, go with a veteran, or draft a rookie, the decision will shape the franchise’s future.

The 2024 season could be a turning point for the Cardinals. If they can find stability at quarterback, they could surprise the league. If not, they may be forced to make drastic changes in the offseason. One thing is certain: the quarterback question will dominate the conversation in Arizona for the foreseeable future.